Resonance / Side by side

Open and stopped pipes: the boundary changes the note

Two cylindrical air columns of the same length can have different lowest resonances because their ends impose different conditions.

What “open” means in the model

At the open end of a narrow tube, pressure variation is approximately small, while air can move. At a rigid stopped end, longitudinal air motion must be small, while pressure variation can be large. These different boundary conditions select different standing-wave patterns.

An ideal cylinder open at both ends fits half a wavelength into its length at the lowest resonance. The same cylinder stopped at one end fits a quarter wavelength. With equal effective lengths, the stopped pipe’s lowest resonance is half the open pipe’s. “Stopped” here means one end closed, not a sealed tube with both ends closed.

Evidence: 1

Work through the numbers

Use an assumed sound speed of 343 metres per second and an effective length of 0.50 metre. The open model gives 343 Hz; the stopped model gives 171.5 Hz. The next open resonances are 686 and 1029 Hz. The next stopped resonances are 514.5 and 857.5 Hz: odd multiples of its lowest resonance.

Now double the length while retaining the same boundary. Every model frequency halves. Changing length and changing the boundary can both lower a note, but they are different operations. The pattern of upper resonances helps distinguish them.

Evidence: 1

Where the tidy model ends

Real pipes have end corrections, finite openings, losses and sometimes tone holes. A clarinet’s reed end is only approximately closed, and its radiation is more complicated than this ideal cylinder. Conical bores, such as those of an oboe or saxophone, require a different model. Do not infer that every instrument with a reed has only odd harmonics, or confuse resonance locations with guaranteed spectral amplitudes.

Evidence: 1

For effective length 0.50 mOpen at both endsStopped at one end
Lowest-mode wavelength1.00 m2.00 m
Lowest resonance at c = 343 m/s343 Hz171.5 Hz
First three ideal resonances343, 686, 1029 Hz171.5, 514.5, 857.5 Hz
Boundary at stopped endNot applicableAir-motion node, pressure antinode
Two ideal formulas

Open cylinder: fₙ = nc/(2L), n = 1, 2, 3… . Cylinder stopped at one end: fₙ = (2n−1)c/(4L), n = 1, 2, 3… . L is effective acoustic length, not automatically the ruler length.

Keep this in mind

A resonator’s allowed modes depend on its boundary conditions as well as its length.

Make the connection

A length becomes a note

Choose an open pipe, then a stopped pipe at the same length. Compare both the first frequency and the sequence of resonances.

Open the experiment ↗

Sources & further reading

These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.

  1. Open vs Closed pipes (Flutes vs Clarinets) ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
Full source and rights register ↗