What “open” means in the model
At the open end of a narrow tube, pressure variation is approximately small, while air can move. At a rigid stopped end, longitudinal air motion must be small, while pressure variation can be large. These different boundary conditions select different standing-wave patterns.
An ideal cylinder open at both ends fits half a wavelength into its length at the lowest resonance. The same cylinder stopped at one end fits a quarter wavelength. With equal effective lengths, the stopped pipe’s lowest resonance is half the open pipe’s. “Stopped” here means one end closed, not a sealed tube with both ends closed.
Evidence: 1
Work through the numbers
Use an assumed sound speed of 343 metres per second and an effective length of 0.50 metre. The open model gives 343 Hz; the stopped model gives 171.5 Hz. The next open resonances are 686 and 1029 Hz. The next stopped resonances are 514.5 and 857.5 Hz: odd multiples of its lowest resonance.
Now double the length while retaining the same boundary. Every model frequency halves. Changing length and changing the boundary can both lower a note, but they are different operations. The pattern of upper resonances helps distinguish them.
Evidence: 1
Where the tidy model ends
Real pipes have end corrections, finite openings, losses and sometimes tone holes. A clarinet’s reed end is only approximately closed, and its radiation is more complicated than this ideal cylinder. Conical bores, such as those of an oboe or saxophone, require a different model. Do not infer that every instrument with a reed has only odd harmonics, or confuse resonance locations with guaranteed spectral amplitudes.
Evidence: 1
| For effective length 0.50 m | Open at both ends | Stopped at one end |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest-mode wavelength | 1.00 m | 2.00 m |
| Lowest resonance at c = 343 m/s | 343 Hz | 171.5 Hz |
| First three ideal resonances | 343, 686, 1029 Hz | 171.5, 514.5, 857.5 Hz |
| Boundary at stopped end | Not applicable | Air-motion node, pressure antinode |
Two ideal formulas
Open cylinder: fₙ = nc/(2L), n = 1, 2, 3… . Cylinder stopped at one end: fₙ = (2n−1)c/(4L), n = 1, 2, 3… . L is effective acoustic length, not automatically the ruler length.
A resonator’s allowed modes depend on its boundary conditions as well as its length.
Make the connection
A length becomes a note
Choose an open pipe, then a stopped pipe at the same length. Compare both the first frequency and the sequence of resonances.
Open the experiment ↗Sources & further reading
These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.
- Open vs Closed pipes (Flutes vs Clarinets) ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated