Resonance / A listening lesson

An air column has boundaries too

Compare ideal open and closed pipes, then see where real wind instruments depart.

The air is the resonating medium

A flute, clarinet or brass instrument contains an air pathway whose pressure and flow respond to excitation. The air does not simply travel down the tube once and make a note. A sustained note involves an oscillating flow and pressure pattern, coupled to a jet, reed or lips. Geometry and openings influence the resonances that participate.

Evidence: 1

Two ideal boundary cases

A uniform open-open cylinder approximately supports a half-wavelength fundamental and harmonics at all integer multiples. A uniform cylinder closed at one end and open at the other supports a quarter-wavelength fundamental, with an ideal sequence of odd multiples. For equal effective lengths, the second model’s lowest frequency is half the first. Those statements describe ideal cylindrical boundary models.

Evidence: 2

Calculate before naming an instrument

With c = 343 m/s and effective length L = 0.50 m, an ideal open-open fundamental is 343 Hz. An ideal open-closed fundamental is 171.5 Hz. A real open end adds an end correction, and tone holes, bore changes, bells and the player’s coupling modify behaviour. A saxophone is not described accurately by calling every reed instrument a closed cylinder.

Evidence: 2

The musical consequence

Different mode patterns influence which registers an instrument can access and how fingerings change effective length. They also interact with the excitation mechanism to shape a sustained spectrum. The resonance lab lets you compare clean boundary assumptions; the wind-instrument studies explain why a real instrument’s spectrum should not be read directly from a simple pipe drawing. A drawing of allowed modes is not a recording.

Evidence: 3

Ideal cylinder modes

Open-open: fₙ = nc/(2L). Open-closed: fₙ = (2n−1)c/(4L), n = 1,2,3… . L is effective length; end correction and losses are omitted.

Keep this in mind

Pipe boundaries predict useful ideal mode patterns, but real wind instruments couple geometry and excitation.

Make the connection

A length becomes a note

At the same length, compare open-open and open-closed model frequencies.

Open the experiment ↗

Sources & further reading

These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.

  1. How do woodwind instruments work? ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Music Acoustics · Undated
  2. Open versus closed pipes ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Music Acoustics · Undated
  3. Brass instrument acoustics: an introduction ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Music Acoustics · Undated
Full source and rights register ↗