Choose fifths and octaves as building blocks
A Pythagorean tuning construction uses 3:2 fifths and 2:1 octaves to generate pitches. Starting from a chosen root, multiply by 3/2 repeatedly and move results by powers of two into a convenient register. This is a mathematical description of a tuning family, not a claim that one person invented all ratio-based tuning or that every historical practice was identical.
Evidence: 1
Two fifths give a whole tone
Take a root of 200 Hz. One fifth reaches 300 Hz; another reaches 450 Hz. Move 450 Hz down one octave and obtain 225 Hz, a ratio of 9:8 above the root. Continue the process and different intervals emerge from the same fifth-and-octave rule. Four fifths, reduced by two octaves, give a major-third ratio of 81:64.
Evidence: 2
The arithmetic reveals a mismatch
Twelve 3:2 fifths do not equal seven 2:1 octaves. Their ratio is 531441/524288, about 1.01364, corresponding to about 23.46 cents. This discrepancy is called the Pythagorean comma. A fixed closed keyboard must accommodate that mismatch somehow; simply insisting that every fifth and every octave close perfectly does not solve the arithmetic.
Evidence: 1
Compare one clear consequence
A Pythagorean major third, 81:64, differs from the selected just major third 5:4 and from the equal-tempered four-semitone third. In the tuning lab, compare their frequency values at the same root and listen with matched settings. The example reveals a consequence of the construction. It does not rank the historical or musical value of the systems.
Evidence: 3
The comma
(3/2)¹² / 2⁷ = 531441/524288. In cents: 1200 log₂(531441/524288) ≈ 23.46. A Pythagorean major third is 81/64 ≈ 407.82 cents.
A chain of exact fifths is coherent, but twelve fifths and seven octaves do not meet exactly.
Make the connection
What does “in tune” mean here?
Compare the selected Pythagorean, just and equal-tempered major-third ratios.
Open the experiment ↗Sources & further reading
These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.
- Harpsichord and Clavichord ↗Neville H. Fletcher / UNSW hosted research chapter · Undated
- Tartini tones and temperament ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Music Acoustics · Undated
- Indifference to dissonance in native Amazonians reveals cultural variation in music perception ↗Josh H. McDermott, Alan F. Schultz, Eduardo A. Undurraga and Ricardo A. Godoy / Nature · 2016-07-28