A tuning is a set of linked decisions
Choosing frequencies for several notes determines many pairwise intervals at once. You cannot independently demand every possible third, fifth and transposition to take a preferred ratio on a fixed set of twelve pitch classes. The conflict comes from the arithmetic of ratios, not from inadequate craftsmanship. Different systems distribute or accommodate it differently.
Evidence: 1
Compare useful aims
Twelve-tone equal temperament offers the same interval ratios after transposition by any whole number of its steps. A selected just-ratio construction can align particular harmonic components exactly within a chosen chord. A Pythagorean construction privileges chains of exact fifths. These are clear properties to compare before attaching broad labels such as natural, modern or correct.
Evidence: 2
The instrument changes the problem
A fixed-pitch instrument commits to a set of frequencies between adjustments. A singer or fretless string player can alter pitch during performance, though ensemble context imposes its own constraints. Piano strings also have inharmonic modes, so practical tuning may stretch octaves to relate prominent partials. An ideal oscillator comparison deliberately leaves these material and performance questions out.
Evidence: 3
Choose a listening question
Ask whether you are comparing a sustained major third, a changing chord progression, a melody against a drone or free transposition. Then hold the irrelevant settings constant. The tuning lab focuses on a few selected intervals and ratios; it cannot represent every tuning tradition or settle aesthetic preference. A precise result is “this setting aligns these two partials” or “this interval is wider by this many cents.”
Evidence: 4
Evaluate a tuning against a musical task, an instrument and clearly stated ratios.
Make the connection
What does “in tune” mean here?
Compare the same interval and root in every available tuning, recording the numerical difference and your observation separately.
Open the experiment ↗Sources & further reading
These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.
- Harpsichord and Clavichord ↗Neville H. Fletcher / UNSW hosted research chapter · Undated
- Tartini tones and temperament ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Music Acoustics · Undated
- How harmonic are harmonics? ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Music Acoustics · Undated
- Indifference to dissonance in native Amazonians reveals cultural variation in music perception ↗Josh H. McDermott, Alan F. Schultz, Eduardo A. Undurraga and Ricardo A. Godoy / Nature · 2016-07-28