Tuning / A listening lesson

Two nearby notes make a slower pulse

Hear a frequency difference become an audible change in amplitude.

The waves drift into and out of alignment

Two sine waves with nearby frequencies do not keep the same relative phase. They alternately reinforce and oppose each other, producing an amplitude fluctuation. For a close pair, the number of loudness pulses per second equals the absolute frequency difference. At 250 and 253 Hz, the model produces three beats per second.

Evidence: 1

The slow pattern is not a third oscillator

The linear sum still consists of the two original frequencies. Its changing envelope makes a slow pulse audible. Nonlinear distortion or hearing can also produce combination tones in some circumstances, but those are a different phenomenon. A spectrum showing two nearby components and a waveform showing a slow envelope can therefore both be correct.

Evidence: 2

Beat rate depends on register

A fixed difference of three hertz gives the same mathematical beat rate at many starting frequencies. A fixed difference in cents instead gives a larger hertz separation at a higher register. Similarly, two nearly aligned harmonics can beat faster than their corresponding fundamentals. This is one reason tuning by partials requires stating which components you are comparing.

Evidence: 3

Follow the transition carefully

Start with a small separation and count the swellings. Increase the difference while keeping levels fixed. At larger separations the listening impression can shift towards roughness or two distinct pitches; there is no single universal threshold independent of frequency and listener. Use the lab’s numerical difference as the controlled fact and your description as an observation of the specific playback.

Evidence: 1

Envelope and beat rate

sin(2πf₁t)+sin(2πf₂t)=2cos(π(f₂−f₁)t)sin(2π((f₁+f₂)/2)t). The absolute amplitude envelope reaches a maximum |f₂−f₁| times per second.

Keep this in mind

Close-frequency beating comes from changing relative phase; its rate is the frequency difference.

Make the connection

When two notes almost agree

Compare separations of 1, 3 and 6 Hz, then contrast a much wider interval.

Open the experiment ↗

Useful words

Beating

Repeated changes in the strength of a combined signal caused by nearby frequencies. For two sine tones, the beat rate equals their absolute frequency difference.

See in glossary ↗

Sources & further reading

These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.

  1. Interference beats and Tartini tones ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Physclips · Undated
  2. Amplitude and phase spectra ↗Chris Donahue / Carnegie Mellon University · 2026
  3. Note names, MIDI numbers and frequencies ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Music Acoustics · Undated
Full source and rights register ↗