Pitch & listening / Side by side

Beating and roughness: from pulses to texture

Two nearby tones can swell slowly or acquire a rapid, grainy interaction. Distinguish a calculable difference frequency from a listener’s perceptual description.

Begin with pulses you can count

Play 220 Hz and 222 Hz sine tones together into the same output. Their relative phase drifts, repeatedly favouring addition then cancellation. The sum’s amplitude has two audible swelling cycles per second. The frequency difference, 2 Hz, predicts that beat rate.

Change the second tone to 225 Hz and the beat rate becomes 5 Hz. Nothing is striking a drum five times each second: the two continuous tones produce a changing combined signal. Unequal amplitudes reduce the depth of the dips; exact silence at a dip requires equal amplitudes in the ideal sum.

Evidence: 1

A larger difference changes the listening task

As the frequency separation grows, individual pulses can become harder to follow and the sound can acquire a rough quality. Eventually listeners may resolve two tones more clearly. There is no single difference-frequency boundary that works for every register, level, timbre and listener.

Compare 220 + 222 Hz, then 220 + 240 Hz, then a much wider interval while keeping duration and component levels consistent. Describe whether you hear separate swellings, a buzzing interaction, or two tones. The arithmetic reports separation; your description reports perception. Neither needs to be forced into a predetermined answer.

Evidence: 2

Do not turn roughness into a universal rule

Complex notes contain many partials, so multiple pairs can interact at once. A chord’s sensory roughness is therefore not determined only by the distance between its fundamentals. Nor does roughness alone determine musical consonance, tension or enjoyment. Cross-cultural research has found that responses to roughness and preferences among chords can differ in their pattern. In this publication, a beat-rate display is a calculation, not a machine judgement of beauty.

Evidence: 2 · 3

QuestionSlow beatingRoughness
DescriptionCountable changes in strengthA rapid, grainy interaction
Example to compare220 and 222 HzTry 220 and 240 Hz; perception varies
Useful measureAbsolute frequency differenceDepends on auditory interaction and context
Does it decide preference?NoNo
Keep this in mind

Beat rate is arithmetic; roughness is a perceptual response that changes with conditions.

Make the connection

When two notes almost agree

Start with a 2 Hz difference and increase it gradually. Note where your description changes without treating it as a hearing test.

Open the experiment ↗

Sources & further reading

These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.

  1. Beats — Physclips ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
  2. Individual differences reveal the basis of consonance ↗Josh H. McDermott, Andriana J. Lehr and Andrew J. Oxenham / Current Biology · 2010-05-27
  3. Indifference to dissonance in native Amazonians reveals cultural variation in music perception ↗Josh H. McDermott, Alan F. Schultz, Eduardo A. Undurraga and Ricardo A. Godoy / Nature · 2016-07-28
Full source and rights register ↗