One word carries several questions
A pair can be described as smooth or rough, fused or separate, stable or needing continuation, pleasant or unpleasant. These are related judgements but not identical ones. In a tonal analysis, consonance often concerns how an interval functions. In a listening experiment, the question may concern roughness or liking. A useful explanation states which judgement it is making.
Evidence: 1
Physics supplies interactions
Nearby frequency components can create amplitude fluctuations. With harmonic sounds, simple frequency ratios can align some partials, changing those interactions. Timbre and register matter because they determine which components are present and how close they are. A calculation of partial coincidence is informative, but it does not by itself establish a listener’s musical preference.
Evidence: 2
Listening experience matters too
A 2016 study by McDermott and colleagues compared participant groups with different musical exposure, including Tsimane’ participants in Bolivia, and found substantial variation in preference for consonant over dissonant sounds. It does not show that physiology is irrelevant or that every individual in a community hears alike. It demonstrates why a preference observed in one population should not be presented as a universal law.
Evidence: 3
Ask a better A/B question
Compare two tunings with the same root, timbre and timing. First describe any audible beating. Next consider whether that difference matters for a sustained chord, a brief melodic figure or a deliberately rough texture. Those are separate musical uses. Keep your preference as a valid observation of your experience without turning it into a claim that one numerical ratio is objectively correct for all music.
Evidence: 4
Acoustic smoothness, stylistic stability and preference are different claims.
Make the connection
What does “in tune” mean here?
Compare a selected interval in two tunings, describing the sound before judging which you prefer.
Open the experiment ↗Useful words
Consonance
A family of terms for musical stability, blending or sensory qualities. Its meaning and preference associations depend on context and listening experience.
See in glossary ↗Sources & further reading
These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.
- Intervals ↗Chelsey Hamm and Bryn Hughes / Open Music Theory · 2023 edition
- Interference beats and Tartini tones ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Physclips · Undated
- Indifference to dissonance in native Amazonians reveals cultural variation in music perception ↗Josh H. McDermott, Alan F. Schultz, Eduardo A. Undurraga and Ricardo A. Godoy / Nature · 2016-07-28
- Tartini tones and temperament ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Music Acoustics · Undated