Two ways to place the upper note
In 12-tone equal temperament, every semitone has the same frequency ratio: the twelfth root of two. Twelve such steps double frequency. A major third spans four steps, so its ratio is 2 to the power of one third, approximately 1.259921.
A selected just major third uses the ratio 5:4, or 1.25. With a 220 Hz root, the equal-tempered upper note is about 277.18 Hz and the just upper note is 275 Hz. The root stays exactly the same; the upper frequency is about 2.18 Hz lower in this just comparison.
Evidence: 1
Why harmonics make the difference audible
Give each note a harmonic spectrum. At a just 5:4 third, the lower note’s fifth harmonic and the upper note’s fourth harmonic meet at 1100 Hz. In the equal-tempered version, the upper fourth harmonic lies around 1108.73 Hz. Nearby components can produce beating. With pure sine waves there are no fourth and fifth partials, so the same interval comparison offers different listening cues.
This is why a fair test needs the same tone colour, duration and overall level. A brief attack may obscure a slow interaction; a richer spectrum can make it easier to notice. You can prefer either result without invalidating the frequency calculation.
Evidence: 2
A local match is not a universal tuning
A fixed just set optimizes selected relationships to its reference. A new root or progression can demand a different version of a note. Equal temperament makes interval ratios transposable across its twelve-note grid, while giving up exact simple ratios for most intervals. These are limited examples among many tuning practices. Neither calculation establishes which system a culture should use or which listeners ought to enjoy.
| With a 220 Hz root | 12-tone equal temperament | Selected just intonation |
|---|---|---|
| Major-third ratio | 2^(4/12) ≈ 1.259921 | 5/4 = 1.25 |
| Upper note | 277.18 Hz | 275.00 Hz |
| Size in cents | 400 cents | About 386.31 cents |
| Design benefit | Same ratios after grid transposition | Exact selected ratios to this root |
| Important tradeoff | Most simple ratios are approximate | Changing harmonic context may require retuning |
Measure the difference
1200 log₂((2^(4/12))/(5/4)) ≈ 13.69 cents. This is the equal-tempered third’s height above the selected 5:4 third; it is independent of the root frequency.
Compare specific intervals and musical contexts; “just” and “equal” describe choices, not a universal quality ranking.
Make the connection
What does “in tune” mean here?
Hold the root and compare the major third in equal temperament and just intonation. Repeat with a harmonic-rich sound and listen for upper-partial interaction.
Open the experiment ↗Sources & further reading
These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.
- Tartini tones and temperament: an introduction for musicians ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
- Beats — Physclips ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
- Indifference to dissonance in native Amazonians reveals cultural variation in music perception ↗Josh H. McDermott, Alan F. Schultz, Eduardo A. Undurraga and Ricardo A. Godoy / Nature · 2016-07-28