Intervals & harmony / Side by side

Close and open voicing: the same chord, rearranged

Keep a chord’s note classes while changing their registers. Listen to how spacing changes texture without changing the basic chord label.

A chord name leaves choices open

A C-major triad identifies the pitch classes C, E and G in a familiar Western harmonic framework. It does not specify their octaves, their order, which notes are doubled, or which instrument plays each one. Voicing supplies those details.

Compare C4–E4–G4 with C3–G3–E4. Both contain C, E and G, and both put C in the bass. The first packs the notes within a fifth; the second spreads them over more than an octave. Moving the middle E above the G opens space without converting the chord to a different triad or changing its bass-defined inversion.

Evidence: 1

Hold the right things steady

Use the same synthetic tone, note count, overall gain and duration for both versions. First move the entire close chord down together. Then spread its voices. These are separate comparisons: transposition changes the whole register; revoicing changes the distances between notes.

For a 12-tone equal-tempered example with A4 = 440 Hz, C3 is about 130.81 Hz, E3 164.81 Hz, and G3 196.00 Hz. Moving only E3 to E4 doubles that component to about 329.63 Hz. The relationships among the instruments’ partials change too. A numerical note list is useful because “wider” otherwise leaves the actual operation ambiguous.

Evidence: 2

Choose a texture, not a winner

Spacious bass voicings are a common arranging choice, including in jazz, but clarity depends on timbre, level and surrounding parts. Dense low chords can be a deliberate colour. The highest voice may become a melody; the lowest can change the harmony’s perceived foundation. Ask what the arrangement needs rather than assuming one spacing sounds better everywhere. A quieter accompaniment may also need room for the melody and for the performer’s physical reach.

Evidence: 1

FeatureClose exampleOpen example
NotesC4–E4–G4C3–G3–E4
Pitch classesC, E, GC, E, G
Bass noteCC
SpanPerfect fifthMajor tenth
What changesCompact registerWider register and different top note
Keep this in mind

A chord label is a family of possibilities; voicing turns it into a particular sound.

Make the connection

Move the chord, change the space

Compare close and open versions at one register. Then move both into a lower register and repeat the comparison.

Open the experiment ↗

Sources & further reading

These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.

  1. Jazz Voicings — Open Music Theory ↗Megan Lavengood / Open Music Theory · 2023 copyright edition
  2. Tartini tones and temperament: an introduction for musicians ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
Full source and rights register ↗