Envelopes & instruments / Side by side

Plucked and bowed: one string, different energy

A pluck releases stored energy. A bow can keep supplying it. Compare the life of a note as well as its spectrum.

How the vibration gets going

A plucked string begins displaced from its resting shape. Releasing it sends disturbances along the string; reflections at its ends produce a combination of standing-wave modes. After the release, the finger or pick no longer supplies energy. Vibration feeds the bridge, body and air while other losses convert energy to heat.

A bowed string is driven by friction. Under suitable playing conditions the string alternates between sticking to the moving bow and slipping. The bow keeps adding energy, allowing a note to continue. This sustained interaction is not equivalent to repeating isolated plucks very quickly.

Evidence: 1 · 2

Listen to the beginning and the tail

Compare an ideal teaching envelope with a 10 millisecond rise followed by a quick fall against one with a 200 millisecond rise and a sustained middle. Keep the pitch, waveform and playback duration fixed. You are testing the broad timing difference associated with a short excitation versus maintained energy, not auditioning a guitar and violin recording.

In an actual pluck, partials can decay at different rates, so the sound changes colour as it fades. The bow can maintain a rich spectrum, but the result depends on bow speed, force and contact position. A shared amplitude envelope applied to a fixed oscillator cannot reproduce that interaction or the directional radiation of an instrument body.

Evidence: 2 · 3

A practical musical choice

A sequence of plucked notes naturally makes individual beginnings easy to locate. A bowed line can connect tones through sustained sound and shape level within a note. Neither mechanism dictates a single expressive character: a player can bow sharply or let a pluck ring. When comparing performances, ask whether you changed the excitation, articulation, damping, or all three.

Evidence: 2 · 1

QuestionPlucked stringBowed string
Energy inputMainly at releaseContinues during bow contact
Typical note evolutionDecay after an onsetCan sustain and change level
Important controlPluck location and displacementBow force, speed and location
What the envelope lab modelsBroad amplitude timingBroad amplitude timing, not stick–slip mechanics
Keep this in mind

Changing the way energy enters a resonator changes both the shape and the possibilities of a musical note.

Make the connection

The beginning changes everything

Compare a short attack and strong decay with a slower attack and sustained level. Keep pitch and tone colour unchanged.

Open the experiment ↗

Sources & further reading

These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.

  1. Strings, standing waves and harmonics ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
  2. The bowed string ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
  3. Sound Synthesis — Handbook for Acoustic Ecology ↗Barry Truax, editor / Simon Fraser University · Undated
Full source and rights register ↗