How the vibration gets going
A plucked string begins displaced from its resting shape. Releasing it sends disturbances along the string; reflections at its ends produce a combination of standing-wave modes. After the release, the finger or pick no longer supplies energy. Vibration feeds the bridge, body and air while other losses convert energy to heat.
A bowed string is driven by friction. Under suitable playing conditions the string alternates between sticking to the moving bow and slipping. The bow keeps adding energy, allowing a note to continue. This sustained interaction is not equivalent to repeating isolated plucks very quickly.
Listen to the beginning and the tail
Compare an ideal teaching envelope with a 10 millisecond rise followed by a quick fall against one with a 200 millisecond rise and a sustained middle. Keep the pitch, waveform and playback duration fixed. You are testing the broad timing difference associated with a short excitation versus maintained energy, not auditioning a guitar and violin recording.
In an actual pluck, partials can decay at different rates, so the sound changes colour as it fades. The bow can maintain a rich spectrum, but the result depends on bow speed, force and contact position. A shared amplitude envelope applied to a fixed oscillator cannot reproduce that interaction or the directional radiation of an instrument body.
A practical musical choice
A sequence of plucked notes naturally makes individual beginnings easy to locate. A bowed line can connect tones through sustained sound and shape level within a note. Neither mechanism dictates a single expressive character: a player can bow sharply or let a pluck ring. When comparing performances, ask whether you changed the excitation, articulation, damping, or all three.
| Question | Plucked string | Bowed string |
|---|---|---|
| Energy input | Mainly at release | Continues during bow contact |
| Typical note evolution | Decay after an onset | Can sustain and change level |
| Important control | Pluck location and displacement | Bow force, speed and location |
| What the envelope lab models | Broad amplitude timing | Broad amplitude timing, not stick–slip mechanics |
Changing the way energy enters a resonator changes both the shape and the possibilities of a musical note.
Make the connection
The beginning changes everything
Compare a short attack and strong decay with a slower attack and sustained level. Keep pitch and tone colour unchanged.
Open the experiment ↗Sources & further reading
These sources support the explanations and model assumptions. Recording credits are listed in the listening panels and the source register.
- Strings, standing waves and harmonics ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
- The bowed string ↗Joe Wolfe / UNSW Sydney · Undated
- Sound Synthesis — Handbook for Acoustic Ecology ↗Barry Truax, editor / Simon Fraser University · Undated